What converts well
Single-note lines convert much better than chords. A melody or riff played one note at a time gives the tracking tool a clear job. Strummed chords, bends and fast runs are harder, and they need more cleanup.
Record a clean signal
Use a direct (DI) signal where you can, through your interface’s instrument input. Amp distortion, chorus, delay and reverb all make detection harder. If you only have an amp recording, expect more cleanup.
A few habits help:
- Mute the strings you aren’t playing. Ringing open strings create extra notes.
- Play evenly, with a consistent attack. Hammer-ons, slides and harmonics are often tracked incorrectly.
- Set the tempo first. Quantize and delete ghost notes after conversion, not before.
Open-string reference
These are the open strings in standard tuning. The MIDI numbers use the convention where middle C is 60.
| String | Note | Frequency | MIDI note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6th (low) | E2 | 82.41 Hz | 40 |
| 5th | A2 | 110.00 Hz | 45 |
| 4th | D3 | 146.83 Hz | 50 |
| 3rd | G3 | 196.00 Hz | 55 |
| 2nd | B3 | 246.94 Hz | 59 |
| 1st (high) | E4 | 329.63 Hz | 64 |
Note names differ by DAW. Most references call MIDI note 40 “E2”, but some DAWs label it “E1”. The low E string has a cycle of about 12 ms, so it tracks a little more slowly than the higher strings. The bass low E at about 41 Hz is a different case, with a cycle of about 24 ms; see the pillar guide.
Offline conversion: single lines
For a single-note line, these tools work well:
- Melodyne’s melodic algorithm, then MIDI export. See the Melodyne guide.
- Ableton Live: Convert Melody. See the Ableton guide.
- Logic Pro: Flex Pitch, then Create MIDI Track from Flex Pitch Data.
- Cubase Pro: VariAudio, then Extract MIDI. See the Cubase guide.
Offline conversion: chords
Chords need a polyphonic tool:
- Melodyne’s editor or studio edition, using the Polyphonic Decay algorithm, which suits plucked and strummed guitar.
- Ableton Live: Convert Harmony.
- Basic Pitch or NeuralNote, both free and polyphonic.
Expect some missing and extra notes in strummed chords, even with a good tool.
Real-time guitar to MIDI
For live playing, real-time converters work as you play:
- MIDI Guitar 3 from Jam Origin is software that tracks polyphonic playing from a normal pickup. No special pickup is needed.
- Hex (divided) pickups send each string separately to a hardware or modeling unit. Roland’s GK series is one example. Fishman TriplePlay pairs a hex pickup with a wireless MIDI transmitter.
Real-time results are usually less precise than offline conversion, because the tool can’t look ahead. Latency also exists, and it is slightly larger on the low strings.
Polyphonic pitch bends need one MIDI channel per string, using a mono mode or an MPE-style setup. If every note shares one channel, a bend on one string bends them all.
Cleanup
- Delete ghost notes from ringing strings.
- Fix octave errors. These show up most in low notes.
- Edit hammer-ons, slides and harmonics by hand, since tools often mis-track them.
- Quantize last, after the notes are right.
Common mistakes
- Assuming you need a hex pickup. Software can work from a normal pickup.
- Expecting zero latency. Real-time guitar-to-MIDI has some lag.
- Expecting strummed chords to transcribe perfectly. Expect missing and extra notes.
- Expecting bends to work on one channel. Polyphonic bends need one channel per string.