Audio to MIDI

How to convert an audio drum track to MIDI in logic?

Convert an audio drum track to MIDI in Logic Pro with Replace or Double Drum Track: pick one drum, set the threshold, then clean up the trigger notes.

On this page
  1. Short answer
  2. Before you start
  3. Run Replace or Double Drum Track
  4. Convert the rest of the kit
  5. Check timing and clean up
  6. Other routes
  7. Common mistakes

Short answer

Yes. In Logic Pro, select the drum track and run Track > Replace or Double Drum Track (Control-D). Logic analyzes the hits of one drum, creates a software instrument track with a sampler, and writes a MIDI region of trigger notes. For the best result, use it on one close-miked drum, such as a kick, snare or tom.

Before you start

  • Isolate one drum. A close-miked kick or snare converts far better than a stereo drum loop, where several drums overlap. Hi-hat bleed on a snare mic causes false triggers.
  • Use stems for a drum loop. Logic Pro 11’s Stem Splitter can isolate drums from a stereo mix, but it can’t separate the kick from the snare. For that you need separate mic tracks or a more specialized tool.
  • Check the transient markers. The Flex Time markers show where Logic thinks the hits are. Correct them first, since they affect the timing of the triggers.

Run Replace or Double Drum Track

  1. Select the drum audio region or track.
  2. Press Control-D, or choose Track > Replace or Double Drum Track.
  3. Set Mode, Instrument, Threshold and the other options (see below).
  4. Click OK. Logic creates a new software instrument track with a MIDI region of trigger notes.

Mode and Instrument

  • Mode: Replace swaps the original audio for the MIDI hits. Double layers the sampler over the original audio, so you keep both.
  • Instrument: Kick, Snare, Tom or Others. This tells the detection what kind of drum to listen for.

Threshold and prelisten

  • Threshold sets how loud a hit must be to create a trigger. Lower it to catch softer hits. Raise it to reject bleed and false hits.
  • Prelisten lets you audition the triggers before you commit to them.
  • Trigger Note sets the MIDI note that plays the sampled sound. For compatibility with General MIDI drum maps, use kick 36, snare 38 and closed hi-hat 42.
  • Timing Offset shifts the triggers earlier or later, so they line up with the original transients.

Convert the rest of the kit

Run the tool once for each drum: the kick, the snare and each tom. Then move the MIDI regions onto one track if you want a single region. Keep the General MIDI note numbers consistent across drums, so the kit maps correctly on any drum instrument.

Check timing and clean up

  • Zoom in and compare the MIDI with the original hits. Delayed notes and missed hits are common.
  • Adjust Timing Offset if every trigger is slightly early or late.
  • Delete or move extra notes where the threshold caught bleed.
  • Velocity follows the detected hit level. Tweak it if the dynamics look wrong.

Other routes

  • Convert to New Sampler Track. Logic slices the audio by transients or regions and maps the slices to a sampler. The notes map to slices, not to General MIDI drum notes, so this gives a different result.
  • Quick Sampler Slice mode. It chops a loop into notes, which is good for playing a loop from the keys but not for transcribing it.
  • Melodyne’s Percussive algorithm through ARA. Another option if you already use Melodyne.

The Cubase guide uses a similar hit-detection approach with Hitpoints.

Common mistakes

  • Expecting one pass to split a full stereo kit. The tool targets one drum type per run.
  • Using Flex Pitch on drums. Flex Pitch is for pitched material.
  • Ignoring bleed. Hi-hat bleed on a snare mic creates false triggers. Raise the threshold or isolate the track.
  • Assuming slices map to General MIDI. Convert to New Sampler Track gives slice notes.

Once the drum MIDI is in, editing it in another DAW is covered in does REAPER have a drum editor.

The complete guide to audio to midi

How to Convert Audio to MIDI Accurately
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →